Skip to Content

Asian Tribune is published by World Institute For Asian Studies|Powered by WIAS Vol. 12 No. 2708

India: Oppositions criticizes Singh on his talks with Gilani but he holds his ground

By M Rama Rao - India Editor, Asian Tribune

New Delhi, 18 July (Asiantribune.com): A day after his summit with Pakistan Prime Minister Syed Yousaf Raza Gilani, Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh is facing lot of flak from the opposition and a section of the media. ‘You have conceded ground and capitulated’, L K Advani, the opposition leader told him in Parliament. Pakistanis must be laughing at India, remarked veteran diplomat G Parthasarathy.

Prime Minister Singh did not agree with this reading of his joint statement with Gilani from Sharmel-Sheikh in Egypt. He held to his view that the ball is still in Pakistan’s court.

‘Whether, when and in what form we broaden the dialogue with Pakistan will depend on future developments’, he said in a detailed statement to Parliament on Friday evening. The next round of Foreign Minister level meetings will take place in September in New York during the UN General Assembly session.

And Singh slipped in the usual caveats: Islamabad must end cross-border terror. It must take sustained, effective and credible action ‘not only to bring the perpetrators of the Mumbai attack to justice but also to shut down the operations of terrorist groups so as to prevent any future attacks’.

‘For the present’, the Prime Minister told the skeptic opposition, ‘we have agreed that the Foreign Secretaries will meet as often as necessary and report to the two Foreign Ministers who will meet on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly’.

The opposition Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) was not satisfied with contention. It leader LK Advani reminded Singh that de-linking of terrorism from composite dialogue has been the ‘demand’ of Pakistan. ‘We have conceded (that demand) seven months after the Mumbai attacks. What has happened that made you change the stance’, Advani asked and thundered ‘The government has capitulated’. Accusing the government of reversing the country's long-standing position that dialogue cannot be pursued if terrorism continues, the BJP led his party lawmakers in a walk out.

US not pressurized India on dialogue

Welcoming the Singh-Gilani meeting, US Secretary of State, who is arriving in Mumbai on Friday night, said, Obama administration has not pressurized India to return to the dialogue table with Pakistan.

In an interview to TV channel, CNN-IBN, she said, ‘No, not at all’, when asked whether the US was putting pressure on Delhi to talk to Islamabad.

‘The dialogue between India and Pakistan is certainly one that could only be pursued with the agreement and commitment of the two countries and the leaders, but of course United States is very supportive with steps that India might take towards any agreement that India and Pakistan might reach’, Clinton said.

Text of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s statement in Parliament:

I returned earlier today from visits to France and Egypt. Before that I had visited Italy for the G-8 / G-5 Summit meetings.

Meetings of the G-8 and G-5 countries have become an annual feature. The agenda for this year’s meetings was wide ranging, but the main focus was on the ongoing global economic and financial slowdown.

The developing countries have been the most affected by the global financial and economic crisis. I stressed the importance of a concerted and well coordinated global response to address systemic failures and to stimulate the real economy. There is a need to maintain adequate flow of finance to the developing countries and to keep markets open by resisting protectionist pressures.

As a responsible member of the international community, I conveyed to the G-8 and G-5 countries that we recognize our obligation to preserve and protect our environment but climate change cannot be addressed by perpetuating the poverty of the developing countries. I presented India’s Action Plan on Climate Change and the eight National Missions which we have set up in this regard. We are willing to do more provided there are credible arrangements to provide both additional financial support as well as technological transfers from developed to developing countries.

India’s participation as guest of honour at the French National Day was an honour and a matter of pride for us all. I wish to share with the Honourable Members the pride I felt to see the brave men of our Armed Forces from all three services leading the French National Day parade. We have a strategic partnership with France. In this spirit, in our discussions, President Sarkozy and I reviewed the entire range of our bilateral cooperation including counter-terrorism and defence cooperation. President Sarkozy was categorical in asserting that France is ready for full civilian nuclear cooperation with India.

In Egypt, I participated in the 15th Summit of the Non-Aligned Movement. NAM is the powerful voice of almost two-third of the world’s nations. I recalled what Pandit Nehru had said about NAM being a moral force in global affairs. The Summit called for bringing decision-making processes in the international system, including the UN and international financial institutions, in tune with contemporary realities. I am glad that our views found widespread resonance and that the Summit heeded our call to strongly condemn international terrorism.

On the sidelines of the Summit, I met with the Presidents of Egypt, Sri Lanka, Vietnam and the Palestinian National Authority, and the Prime Ministers of Bangladesh, Malaysia, Nepal and Pakistan. I found a uniform desire among all these countries to further enhance their relations with India.

During my meeting with Prime Minister Gilani of Pakistan yesterday, we discussed the present condition of India-Pakistan relations, its future potential and the steps that are necessary to enable us to realize the potential.

I conveyed to him the strong sentiments of the people of India over the issue of terrorism, especially the terrorist attacks in Mumbai. We are reviewing the dossier of investigations into these attacks which Pakistan has provided to us. I also conveyed to Prime Minister Gilani that sustained, effective and credible action needs to be taken not only to bring the perpetrators of the Mumbai attack to justice, but also to shut down the operations of terrorist groups so as to prevent any future attacks.

It has been and remains our consistent position that the starting point of any meaningful dialogue with Pakistan is a fulfillment of their commitment, in letter and spirit, not to allow their territory to be used in any manner for terrorist activities against India.

Prime Minister Gilani assured me that Pakistan will do everything in its power to bring the perpetrators of the Mumbai attacks to justice. He also told me that there is consensus in Pakistan against the activities of these terrorist groups, that strong action is being taken and that this is in Pakistan’s own interest. The distinguished parliamentarians from different parties who accompanied the Pakistan Prime Minister also said to me that there was political consensus in Pakistan on this issue.

As the Joint Statement says, action on terrorism should not be linked to the composite dialogue process, and therefore cannot await other developments. It was agreed that the two countries will share real time, credible and actionable information on any future terrorist threats.

Whether, when and in what form we broaden the dialogue with Pakistan will depend on future developments. For the present, we have agreed that the Foreign Secretaries will meet as often as necessary and report to the two Foreign Ministers who will meet on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly.

As I have said before in this House, India seeks cooperative relations with Pakistan, and engagement is the only way forward to realize the vision of a stable and prosperous South Asia living in peace and amity. We are willing to go more than half way provided Pakistan creates the conditions for a meaningful dialogue. I hope that there is forward movement in the coming months.

I have returned home convinced that these interactions with world leaders have served to further advance India’s interests’.

-Asian Tribune -

Share this


.